Accountability Betsy DeVos Billionaires Bloomberg Corporate Reform Education Industry Failure Fraud Hoax Michael Michelle Privatization Rhee Teach for America

Gary Rubinstein: How to Pretend to Reform Schools

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

Gary Rubinstein revisits the past decade of failed reforms and notes how frequently the “reformers” made promises and then failed to keep them. Michelle Rhee came on the national scene, appearing on the cover of TIME, then disappeared after helping to sink the mayor of D.C. who hired her. Michael Bloomberg and Joel Klein claimed that under their leadership, there was a “miracle” in New York City, but the miracle disappeared when they and their public relations team left office. Jeb Bush touted a Florida “miracle,” but Florida remains mired in the depths of mediocrity when assessed by NAEP. Laurene Powell Jobs promised to “reinvent” the high school and handed out $100 millions to the schools she chose; many failed soon after. We await the “miracle.” Even Betsy DeVos claimed to be “rethinking” school, wondering why we needed public schools at all; now she is busy spreading millions to charter and voucher advocates in the red states.

Gary concluded his review of all the rethinking, reinventing, and rebranding by taking a close look at a school hyped by TFA. He looked at the numbers, and lo and behold, no miracle there.

In this “model” school, the kids are faring poorly:

OK, “So what,” you say, “only 1.1% of their 10th graders passed the science test and 2.7% of their 10th graders passed the math test. What matters is ‘growth.” Well in that department they didn’t fare so well either.

He concludes:

Usually it’s a lot harder than this. They often pick a school that has artificially inflated test scores due to attrition. Keep in mind, this is the school Villanueva Beard chose to highlight. One of the lowest performing schools in test scores and growth in the state of Indiana.

Whether they are ‘rethinkers,’ ‘reinventers,’ or ‘reimaginers’, a reformer by any other name still doesn’t know anything about schools.

The burning question is: When will the billionaires who fund “reform” and “reinvention” decide to stop funding failure?

Related posts

The New York Times Should Add a Former Teacher to Its Editorial Board


Carol Burris Rates the Candidates at the Public Education Forum in Pittsburgh


San Antonio: Carpe Diem Charter School Will Close in June


Missouri: New State School Board Uncertain About How to Evaluate Charters


Valerie Jablow: D.C., Wholly Owned by the Billionaire Boys Club


Maurice Cunningham: How Billionaires’ Dark Money Shapes Education Policy


Leonie Haimson: Biden’s Absurd Decision to Impose the Tests: Opt Out!


Jan Resseger: Why Ohio Should Not Give More Money to Charter Schools


Senate Republicans Want to Increase Funding for Charters, House Democrats Want to Cut it


Leave a Comment